They used to be more affordable, I remember being able to get tickets off Groupon and TDF but for some reason any and all discounts have slowly disappeared. Groupon especially had great deals, I paid around $35 a ticket for Forum, Millie, and OOTI and they were all pretty decent orchestra seats. The last thing I saw there was Hunchback and my ticket was last row orchestra for $90 and that may have had a discount applied since my friend did Oliver there and was able to get us something.
The cheapest way to go to Papermill is as a subscriber, so I would suggest the 4-5 show package which makes the shows much more reasonable. If you're not in the area and can't do the package expect to be spending Broadway-ish prices. Its really a shame it got so expensive.
Updated On: 4/24/18 at 03:14 PM