I don't think he ever played Marius on tour. I saw him as Marius on Broadway 5 times. I thought he was absolutely perfect in the role and think the negative commentary is unfounded. His was the first Marius I really cared about. Not that the others were bad, but Peters attention to detail and his sincerity gave the character greater depth.
I couldn't imagine him as Valjean when I read an article some time ago in which it was mentioned he played Valjean in a regional production. I think that production was in Hawaii, but don't quote me on that.
Anyhow, I had trouble just imagining him
looking the role, but then I did some Googling and he looked great in his fake, white beard, hehehe.
If Drew Sarich made for a decent Valjean, I'm sure Peter could pull it off. I say that only because there seems to be a general preference for older, gruffy sounding men for the role. When someone not fitting that iconic Colm Wilkinson description is said to be eyeing the role, people fall apart. The only reason I had trouble seeing Peter working in the role had more to do with the fact he WAS Marius to me, rather than any of that shallow "type" bull, lol.
I'd love to see his Valjean, but he'll always be Marius to me! :)
Recreation of original John Cameron orchestration to "On My Own" by yours truly. Click player below to hear.