I can only say that I have been taught through grade school, college, and grad school (yes, I hold an MFA in theatre) as well as professional regional theatre that you NEVER EVER EVER EVER put the title of a play or musical in quotes. EVER.
When we were taught in grand detail how to do our bibliographies in research papers and my honors thesis, we were taught to do it this way.
It is indeed possible that AP says one thing and MLA says another and blah blah blah. Look in any Playbill, and you will see the proper way to treat plays, musicals, operas, films, TV shows, songs, albums, publications, etc. etc. etc. in the professional theatre when regarding quotes. Playbill chooses to use italics--some theatres use bold print or underlining, which are fine as well.
So, as a professional artist of the theatre, I shall continue to follow professional THEATRE guidelines.
You do what pleases you. Just know your audience.
jrb
Updated On: 8/28/05 at 02:30 AM