I just rushed American Psycho on Monday. Got there around 9-ish and was 5th in line. I could see the Shuffle Along line from across the street, and I don't remember when people started lining up, but I do remember that the line got long fairly quickly. When I rushed The Color Purple, I got there a little after 7 and was 3rd or 4th in line. I don't think anyone else joined the line until 8-ish, but I could be remembering that wrong. Waitress offers standing room instead of rush, and I think they only offer it when the show is sold out. Not sure about Bright Star, but it looks like someone else covered that one. Good luck, and I hope you enjoy your visit!
"I have maggots in my scrotum!"