I saw this last night, and I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed it. However, I can definitely see how it's not for everyone. The mix of real and surreal won't float everyone's boat, but I found it incredibly enchanting and emotionally resonant. The whole play is written very poetically (the title even comes from a T.S Elliott poem), which is the sort of thing I really like, like The Fantasticks, Charles III, Sarah Ruhl's work, etc. Not to say that this play is necessary similar to those other works, but they are all things that I love for their poetic language. To me, the play felt like a mix of Thornton Wilder, Tom Stoppard and Sara Ruhl, with bits of Tennessee Williams - all of whom are playwrights that I love.
Though Zachary Quinto and the rest of the cast does a great job, the real star of the show for me was 14-year-old Taylor Richardson. Her performance, especially in the first act, is very impressive. Her character is silent, and the degree to which Richardson can express herself through her eyes, her face and her body is astounding. She nearly made me cry just with a facial expression.