I caught this last night and think it could have been a really edgy play in like 1992. It covered well-trodden ground that we've seen better tackled in other plays, TV shows and films. At this very moment you can see a much better bi-sexual storyline on Crazy Ex-Girlfriend with Darryl (I'm both-sexual!) and White Josh's budding romance. The gay members of the threesome of sorts in Straight are 20 and 26 years old. The 20 year old makes a big deal about the 26 year old being so old, but it would have made the play much more interesting if he actually were old. Part of what makes Darryl's story work so well is that he's an older divorced man with a daughter who is realizing that while he still is attracted to women, he has been suppressing his interest in men these years.
Straight's two couples are on very unequal footing. Ben and Emily have been dating for five years and are contemplating moving in together. Ben and Chris are a craigslist/grindr hook-up that turns somewhat serious, but Emily knows nothing about. Unfortunately this forces Emily to be played as the most unobservant and dense person ever (she literally finds them passed out on the couch together IN THEIR UNDERWEAR and assumes they were just out for wild night of drinking).
The actors fair better when the dialogue is serious rather than comedic. There are some laughs to be found, but more of the groaning variety than genuine ha ha funny.
Unlike After Eight, I did like the ending and think it led to a realistic conclusion, but it wasn't enough to completely salvage the play. The runtime is 90 minutes and it does go by quickly.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!