The show gets a positive review from Variety.
http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117930724?categoryid=1265&cs=1 "Sometimes you've just got to have a little faith. Though there's more than a touch of familiarity in the early scenes of "Saint Heaven," the earnest little musical receiving its world preem at Connecticut's Stamford Center for the Arts, there's also some smart writing, appealing songs and touching performances. With continued work, this under-the-radar piece could prove to be a popular product for small and midsized stages."
"You might at first think you have sat in this theatrical pew before ("Abyssinia?" "The Color Purple?"). But Casella's script -- based on Steve Lyons' unpublished novel "The Gift of Tongues" -- deepens as the narrative develops. The pastor, housekeeper and buddy show unexpected shadings and offer surprising plot developments. Even the traditional love story evolves into a richer relationship. The musical has a nontraditional closing scene that is nonetheless soul-satisfying."