Broadway212, you're asking the wrong person. I have a huge bias (Saved is one of my favorite movies and Celia is my favorite actress, I also love Aaron and Curtis), so the whole cast could've basically sat on the stage or read the phone book for 2 and a half hours and I would've loved it. That being said, I saw the second preview, and Celia (Keenan-Bolger), Julia (Murney), and Mary (Faber) were all fantastic vocally, and the girl who played Cassandra whose name I don't remember was a standout as well. Aaron Tveit has a smaller role, and I thought Van Hughes as Patrick acted well, but wasn't outstanding vocally. The show itself was cute and a lot more dramatic than I expected (see the movie first, there are some in-jokes), and it does need some work at the climax, as everyone's been saying. Oh, and the songs were alright-not a strong point, but not a weak point either. I'd definately recommend it to anyone, though, and I'll certainly be back.
(By the way, they sell Saved-themed drinks in the lobby at intermission, which I thought was adorable.)
"My muffin top is all that/whole grain and low-fat/I know you want a piece of that/But I just wanna dance!"