Steel Pier...was it really that bad? — Page 3

You are right about the cast album. It is exceptionally well-produced even for RCA Victor who at the time had no real competitors in the cast album field. But the album did not make it into stores until a month after the final performance.

In some ways though it repeats the scenario from the original MERRILY WE ROLL ALONG album in that it encourages those who didn't see the show to think it was some overlooked gem. In small ways it is, as there are some nice moments. In addition to the ones already mentioned I will add two of my own: the finale from Act One where Bill makes time roll backwards was very effectively staged. And the tender final dance was simple, elegant and touching. If only the whole show had been at the level of these moments.

---