Sweeney Todd Recordings

#1

Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:43pm

Sorry for all of these threads, but I have to get my Christmas list together! I have never heard a lot of Sweeney Todd...and I have heard wonderful things about this show. What would you say is the best recording to get?

---

CCM '10!

#2

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:44pm

OBC without a doubt.

---

PEACE.

#3

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:46pm

That's a tough, tough call. The performances on the OBCR (it is OBCR, right?) are so brilliant, but the concert recording is MUCH more complete, with great performances too, and a stellar orchestra. Landsbury will always be the definitive Mrs. Lovett. I will say I bought the concert recording immediately when in come out, and haven't listened to the OBCR once since. Again, it's preference. I just prefer the completeness of the new recording.

---

"What the hell happened to you? You look like a Make-A-Wish Kid. You know, I just knew you were gonna bring shame on this new family of ours, and it just figures you had to go make yourself over into some heroin-shootin skate board chic on the only day E! could interview you!" - Cherry Cherry, on her daughter Mary Cherry

#4

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:47pm

That's true, except you have to suffer LaPattie's Lovett.

---

PEACE.

#5

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:49pm

Which one has the best voices on it?

---

CCM '10!

#6

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:52pm

You know, I didn't like LuPone at first because I was so used to Landsbury. Then, I let it go and tried to just judge LuPone based on what she was doing, not what Landbury did.

Again, overall, I have to go with the Concert. The sound is better, it's a lot more complete (including some hysterical dialogue), and cast wise it's pretty darn good too.

---

"What the hell happened to you? You look like a Make-A-Wish Kid. You know, I just knew you were gonna bring shame on this new family of ours, and it just figures you had to go make yourself over into some heroin-shootin skate board chic on the only day E! could interview you!" - Cherry Cherry, on her daughter Mary Cherry

#7

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:55pm

This the one?

---

CCM '10!

#8

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 6:56pm

Yes, that's it. I like the concert version better to be honest although Lansbury IS Ms. Lovett.

---

"They're eating her and then they're going to eat me. OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!" -Troll 2

#9

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 7:07pm

I have the OBC and it's great, but there's one thing I'd recommend even more. If you feel like having a visual too, the Sweeney dvd is awesome. George Hearn and Angela Lansbury are wonderful together.

#10

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 7:15pm

The disco single THE BALLAD OF SWEENEY TODD, released on 12" red vinyl in 1979 and replete with grisly sound effects.
Once heard, never forgotten.

#11

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:00pm

Tough decision, and there are numerous reasons to get each.
To be brief, though I'll always love the OBC, and Lansbury will always be Mrs. Lovett, the Concert Revording is better if for no other reason but to hear Sondheim's glorious score played by a full symphonic orchestra.

And Hearn's Todd is better sung than Cariou's.

---

"One no longer loves one's insight enough once one communicates it."

The opposite of creation isn't war, it's stagnation.

#12

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:05pm

I agree about Hearns Sweeney being more well sung but I absolutely love Carious take on the demon barber. I say go for the legendary performance of Angela Lansbury as your deciding factor.

---

BSoBW2: I punched Sondheim in the face after I saw Wicked and said, "Why couldn't you write like that!?"

#13

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:07pm

It is really choosing between an A+ recording and an A++ one.

I also feel that the supporting roles are better sung on the Concert Recording.

And Sum, yes, Cariou did act the role better, in my opinion. But no one can match Hearn's magnificent baritone.

---

"One no longer loves one's insight enough once one communicates it."

The opposite of creation isn't war, it's stagnation.

#14

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:10pm

Totally with you on that one. I admire Hearns versatility, to go from the Demon Barber of Fleet Street to the flamboyant homosexuality of ZaZa! It really is tremendous and the sign of an old pro who knows his way around a character.

However I feel the raw emotion plays out better in Carious version, the more subtle details and nuances of character are more fully understood in his voice.

---

BSoBW2: I punched Sondheim in the face after I saw Wicked and said, "Why couldn't you write like that!?"

#15

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:23pm

Apples and Oranges, boys. Hey, get them both and make a fruit salad!

---

PEACE.

#16

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:42pm

I have a plan. I will ask for the concert recording for Christmas and buy the other with my Christmas money!

---

CCM '10!

#17

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:43pm

BAM!!! Great idea.

---

"They're eating her and then they're going to eat me. OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!" -Troll 2

#18

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:45pm

LOL...I am pretty fart smeller! (did I really just say that?)

---

CCM '10!

#19

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:45pm

hahaha

---

"They're eating her and then they're going to eat me. OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD!!!!" -Troll 2

#20

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 8:46pm

That's a good idea. You may be able to find the OBC used for much cheaper than you would the concert version. Check Amazon.com - they have them both. I'm sure there are a probably a ton of used copies available.

---

"What the hell happened to you? You look like a Make-A-Wish Kid. You know, I just knew you were gonna bring shame on this new family of ours, and it just figures you had to go make yourself over into some heroin-shootin skate board chic on the only day E! could interview you!" - Cherry Cherry, on her daughter Mary Cherry

#21

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 10:07pm

I like the concert version A BIT better. It really is choosing between an A+ and an A++ recording. I'm a big LuPone fan though. Angela IS THEE Mrs. Lovett, but I just like the way that LuPone sings it. Angela's got the comedic time though that I like better.

#22

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 10:09pm

I sure hope I get this from Mrs. Clause.

---

CCM '10!

#23

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 10:10pm

OBCR is the best, though I'm not a big fan of the man who plays sweeney. Perhaps you might want to invest in the DVD with Angela Landsbury.

---

"I am ready to disclaim my opinion, even of yesterday, even of 10 minutes ago, because all opinions are relative. One lives in a field of influences, one is influenced by everyone one meets, everything is an exchange of influences, all opinions are derivative. Once you deal a new deck of cards, you've got a new deck of cards." — Peter Brook

#24

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/1/04 at 10:11pm

Not a fan of Len Cariou?

---

"One no longer loves one's insight enough once one communicates it."

The opposite of creation isn't war, it's stagnation.

#25

re: Sweeney Todd Recordings

Posted: 12/2/04 at 1:05pm

though I own both, I think I prefer the Concert with Hearn/LuPone. Though the OBC has Lansbury and a terrifically theatrical sound, the concert is just stunning with a wonderful supporting cast as well. Hearn has always been Sweeney for me and for him to attack that role so brilliantly 20 years later was just astounding to watch night after night. oh, did I mention I was actually IN the chorus for the NYC concerts? :)