Urinetown Caroline, or Change The Light in the Piazza Hairspray Wicked The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee Avenue Q Next to Normal The Wild Party (LaChiusa) The Full Monty
Honorable Mentions:
The Drowsy Chaperone Mamma Mia Movin' Out Jane Eyre Bombay Dreams The Witches of Eastwick
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
Héhé... Okay seriously, no particular order though.
The Last 5 Years Grey Gardens The Light in the Piazza Caroline, Or Change The Wild Party (LaChiusa) The Drowsy Chaperone Next to Normal Avenue Q Hairspray Keating! The Muscial (I had to throw one non-American show in there!)
Wicked Hairspray Mary Poppins Next to Normal Jersey Boys In the Heights Shrek the Musical The Light in the Piazza Thoroughly Modern Millie Legally Blonde
in no particular order: Wild Party (La Chuisa) Wicked Billy Elliot Next to Normal Caroline, or Change Hairspray Light in the Piazza Grey Gardens Spring Awakening The Producers
honorable mentions for being such huge fat hits: Mamma Mia Jersey Boys
I can only give you a top 10. If I lived in NYC and got to see more musicals, I could give you a top 10 :)
1. HAIRSPRAY (One of the longest running shows of the decade, and deservingly so. Fun, energetic, wonderful score, and it introduced to us a whole new generation of Broadway stars). 2. AVENUE Q (As original as it gets. The little show that could). 3. WICKED (Like it or hate it, it's a juggernaut that will be with us for a long time. It makes the top 10 by its sheer contribution to Broadway this decade, financially and otherwise). 4. JERSEY BOYS (As someone said before.. a jutebox musical done right. Another one that will eventually rank among the longest running musicals of all time). 5. AIDA (Beautiful yet versatile score). 6. THE PRODUCERS (It brought back the good ol' fashioned musical, and proved that audiences would still eat it up).