Just to throw my 2 cents in to the discussion here, while I too agree that there is a slight "disjoint" that occurs between the 2 acts, I think some people forget that over 30 years occurs between them. The audience is supposed to see where the progression for both characters could occur, not see the actual progression itself. I personally feel that Miss Davie does a splendid job with tackling the formative years of a very iconic woman. A lot of people are so familiar with the documentary, and Edie is so memorable, the only comparison I can think of is the flack that Hayden Christenson received for his portrayals of young Anakin Skywalker.
While I never saw Sarah Gettelfinger in the role, based on her performance on the original album, I see a much more believable transition between Erin and Christine than Sarah and Christine.
Yes that's me. No, it's not a Rent homage.