I actually saw the show last Sunday and it was a delight. Brad Oscar and Hunter Foster are indeed wonderful. The show was worth it (for me personally), just because of Gary Beach. There's no one better. Brad Musgrove is playing Carmen right now. Bill Nolte just joined the cast 2 weeks ago, and he's a great Franz.
I believe there's going to be casting changes in the upcoming weeks. John Treacy Egan is replaced Brad Oscar Oct. 25th, and Jai Rodriguez is coming in as Carmen November 1st.
"The sense that everything's going right is a sure sense that everything's going wrong."
-The Goat, or Who Is Sylvia?