You know, I think I'm going to have to respectively disagree. Yes, the piece is firmly a product of its time. I'm not going to begin to liken it to something like COMPANY, but I think THE WIZ at least deserves the chance to have a completely new take on it. If I remember correctly, I believe I heard a few years ago that it is being approached as a sort of enviromental production. I always got the impression, and indeed feel that the show would work quite well as a story that surrounds the audience. In it's current state, it's very flat - it knows it's performing (in many instances) to the audience. Why not take an entirely different approach? It's theatre! Honestly, the only Broadway production I've seen of this show was a video of the 80s revival with Stephanie Mills. To be honest, I was SEVERELY disappointed with the production. The tempos were outrageous, the set was terrible, and several cast members were, shall we say lackluster. The piece needs fresh blood and a fresh approach.
I do agree that many of the song titles, lyrics and book elements are steeped heavily in the 70s venacular. If one were to look at contemporary music, up until the last 5 or so years, many of our bass beats, chords, etc were based on 70s-80s music. Our theatre scene hasn't even gotten close to "contemporary" music, so why are we fretting when updates are to occur to an old score?
Some songs are stick out like a sore thumb... for example, "WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE?" is written into the book terribly. THE WIZ, as a show, will probably be BETTER with a book revision. With that comes score updates, etc.
As far as cramming in hip hop beats, I don't think we need to worry about this for much of the score. Not all "contemporary" music has this feel to it. Besides, I don't think you could take songs like "BELIEVE IN YOURSELF" and morph it successfully to this! The score is all around in terms of musical genres, and I think the updates will reflect this.
THE WIZARD OF OZ is a fantastical story that's embedded in audiences minds. The only thing that, in written form, makes THE WIZ a "black" piece is it's lyrical/dialogue usage. In today's society, our accepted vocabulary includes so many slang & ethnic tonalities, words and phrases that we've become very uni-centric (my term..probably not the best, but I'm tired!) Are the ideals or ultimate "points" that this "black" version of THE WIZARD OF OZ utilizes that different from current times? THE WIZ, at its core, is just an example of story telling. I don't see any problem using the widest variety of cast members to tell it. But, then again, unless a story specifically states that "so and so" should be of a certain race or creed, I think it's USUALLY fair game. Why must Dorothy be black? Just because of her songs?
To share a story I received a while back, through an email group (with thanks to its author)...
"The first time I met Sondheim was in January 1980. I was a senior in college, had written Sondheim a letter, and he agreed to meet me during my Christmas break. One question I asked him was, other than his own work, what shows of recent vintage had impressed or moved him. He said "The Wiz". He saw my look of shock and amazement, and went on to explain. Here, 26 years later, is my memory of that response: "Three reasons, primarily. First, the song "Ease on Down the Road". Do you know the word prosody? It's how words sit on music. That lyric was born to sit on that piece of music. It's incredibly rare when you get music and lyrics to match so perfectly. Second, I thought the staging of the tornado was brilliant. Third, the song "Home". I've learned that we tend to most respect that which we cannot do. I could never write a song that sentimental, and I'm in awe of people who can...and who can do it well." "
I don't know, call me crazy, but I think this production could be quite good. And if anyone has connections to La Jolla, I'm only a few hours away and happy to work for little pay
One quick question for Margo: If you don't mind, I'm interested to see how you think the piece would be self-conscious with slang updates. Perhaps I don't see how it is any different than using "current" slang in it's original production?
Feel free to discuss,
Charlie Piane
charlie@pianeproductions.org
Updated On: 5/1/06 at 01:37 AM