I had a subscription to Playbill, and it was very erratic--sometimes it would arrive and sometimes I would just never get it. But maybe I was just unlucky!
(Of course, if you go to a fair number of B'way shows, you might want to skip a subscription to Playbill, since it really is pretty much the same content as what you get in the theater--minus anything specific they might put in about a particular show.)
Maggie-the-schnoodle