Those are my favorites as far as emotional attachment.... and hours of listening to the recording.....
However as far as productions go... i keep to the idea that Billy Elliot was probably the best production / show I ever saw..... but it doesn't even make my favorite 25 list. lol.
Man, this was difficult! I won't even attempt to put these in any kind of order, except to say that my #1 is most definitely "Rent"! After that, my list is in no particular order because I don't feel like sitting here for 6 hours tearing my hair out. LOL
1. RENT 2. Les Miserables 3. Avenue Q 4. Wicked 5. Company 6. The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee 7. Hairspray 8. Billy Elliot 9. La Cage aux Folles 10. Into the Woods 11. Grey Gardens 12. Next to Normal 13. Aspects of Love 14. Hair 15. Sunday in the Park with George 16. The Book of Mormon 17. Gypsy 18. Spring Awakening 19. The Phantom of the Opera 20. In the Heights 21. Urinetown 22. The Drowsy Chaperone 23. Chess 24. Rock of Ages 25. The Light in the Piazza
As you can tell, I'm not overly fond of the old musicals. They just don't resonate with me enough to include on a Top 25 list. I love all things Sondheim, so paring down which of his shows to include was perhaps most difficult of all for me.
1. Wicked 2. Hairspray 3. Phantom of the Opera 4. Rent 5. Les Miserables 6. Spring Awakening 7. Next to Normal 8. Beauty and the Beast 9. Billy Elliot 10. Aida 11. My Fair Lady 12. The Lion King 13. Hair 14. In the Heights 15. Gypsy 16. West Side Story 17. Mary Poppins 18. The Sound of Music 19. The Wizard of Oz 20. Grease 21. Chess 22. Avenue Q 23. The Little Mermaid 24. Chicago 25. Sweeney Todd
It got harder to rank towards the bottom of the list, and a few of these are based on soundtracks, etc. 21.
1. HAIRSPRAY 2. Avenue Q 3. West Side Story 4. Annie Get Your Gun 5. Hello, Dolly! 6. Guys and Dolls 7. Gypsy 8. Chicago 9. Annie 10. A Chorus Line 11. Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat 12. 42nd Street 13. Oklahoma! 14. Beauty and the Beast 15. The Lion King 16. Les Mis 17. Aida 18. Grease 19. Showboat 20. The Life
I have to stop at 20. Listing five more would be disingenuous of me.