" but it certainly wasn't a failure."
A failure is NOT a flop.
Flop = financial.
A failure is a critical mess. Disaster. What have you. I don't think the WiW did well with the critics.
Therefore, despite whether or not you enjoyed it, it was a flop and a failure. F squared.
When the book was written, and how long the show played, mean nothing.
Jekyll & Hyde ran 4 years (FOUR!) ~ never recouped its initial investment, was not a critical success...thus, also F squared.
The smallest stream is a valent river. It will drown me if it can.