"Definitely not gothic & no power ballads here.
Something tells me the critics still would trash it. A few numbers sounded calypsolike & like they could have been from Havana. "
I think the core creative team of Wildhorn, Murphy & Boyd are trying really hard to make it a hit. Surpringly, with nearly every new announcement I tend to get less & less excited.
I've always said the casting of Dacal was a bad decision - first she doesn't look like anyone would expect of Alice. I still firmly believe with a character like Alice, you need the whole blonde-hair-thing going on. Second off, BASED OFF THE RECORDING, she doesn't sound like that big of a stand-out. I'm hoping I'll be blown away by her in person.
Luckily the visuals/scenic/etc. look really great! Some of the music is fine, but again, majority isn't very Wildhorn-sounding. "Worst Day of My Life" sounds like it's from Legally Blonde; most of the songs just repeat themselves over & over.
Just for your folks on BWW I guess, this was on the Wonderland Study Guide (and worried even me!):
"With book musicals, the composer and lyricist who compose the score are
instrumental in the conception and creation of the musical, working closely with a
playwright or writing the script themselves.
Over the years, there have been many notable composer-lyricist pairings that have made their mark on the theatrical scene: Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein, Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice,
and Frank Wildhorn and Jack Murphy.
Wonderland Study Guide