Wicked- Page 2
Wicked
#25re: Wicked
Posted: 9/3/06 at 6:51pm
ThereIs1Director:
""You didn't miss much, Eden is actually pretty bad vocally as Elphie."
You Obviously Never saw Idina Menzel Then."
I totally agree with that. Idina Menzel is my favorite Elphaba and always will be. I think Eden is a great vocalist. Although I haven't seen her in Wicked, I was expecting people to praise her after I heard Once Upon A Time from Brooklyn.
MARIAN: Well, what would you like to take out?
HAROLD HILL: The librarian.
MARIAN: Quiet, please!
HAROLD HILL: (whispering)The librarian.
I would like to invite you to Voices for Rent! The Official Rent fanbase! Come and join your fellow RENTheads!
ThankstoPhantom
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/13/05
#26re: Wicked
Posted: 9/3/06 at 7:36pm^I don't think they meant that as a complement to Idina's vocals.
#27re: Wicked
Posted: 9/3/06 at 8:02pmAlthough I am partial to Idina as Elphie, she being my favorite, Eden is amazing. I've seen her twice, and she is absolutely fabulous. I don't know how anyone could say anything bad about her performance. She is incredible.
bwayondabrain
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/20/05
#28re: Wicked
Posted: 9/3/06 at 8:06pm
wow, i am suprised this is a WICKED thread not over-run by sarcasm
good job, guys! :)
anyhow, ive only seen Shoshana, and her voice was incredible, but i cant compare her to anyone else
i think Eden must be fairly good- she certainly has the voice
#29re: Wicked
Posted: 9/3/06 at 8:20pmGuys, this isn't a "Which Elphaba is the Best" thread, someone saw the show and commented on it. There are plenty of other threads for this topic.
Videos