I just want to add that going to a non-theater driven school doesn't mean you can't do study theater for those four years. I go to a liberal arts university in a large city and the school's theater dept is a joke, but if you are in a relatively large city, there are plenty of great places to take acting classes and audition for all sorts of things. Also, definitely go and visit amda and other places for yourself, you never know what's right for you until you actually see it. Personally, I would rather have the experience of auditioning for four years, but that's just me. Good luck in whatever you choose!
"Commit a little mortal sin, its good for the soul"