I'm going to have to agree with RAY, Roger Bart and Gary Beach are the only reasons I didn't walk out of this movie. It is so poorly directed, one wonders why anyone let it get to the big screen.
I am a huge fan of Mel Brooks, Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick, but come on guys all of you have done movies before, you should care about your craft and not make a mockery of it. If they were in college, I would suggest they go back to ACTING 099. You don't get any credit for it but at least you can call yourself an actor.
I was shocked to find that I hated this movie more than the RENT disaster, Just when I thought Movie musicals were a good idea.
--"Zero Mostel was, in fact, the Broadway character actor. Mel Brooks even said that in '68 he was only known to New Yorkers. Gene Wilder was even less famous, only having had a small role in BONNIE AND CLYDE."--
Yes this is true, but they had something Nathan and Matthew don't DELIVERY & TIMING. I think Roger Ebert put it best when he said that... and I'm paraphrasing, "Uma desrves to dance and sing without the audience thinking that Lee Meredith is standing just offstage arms crossed tapping her foot!" I think these guys have big shoes to fill, they are the "ROAD SHOW" Cast to the original movie. Many of the jokes I could see laughing at in a theatre, but they don't translate directly to the big screen. The WHITE OFFICE scene I think is very funny on stage, deserving of the two of them hamming it up for five minutes. However, In the film theres no reason for the pause, we get it... move on... Hopefully, this won't be the downfall of the Movie Musical, but if they continue to be this awful perhaps its for the best! I can't have my heart break one more time!
P.S. RE: HOSTEL Eli Roth actually got a Pardon from Iceland before making HOSTEL. He thought it might put Icelanders in a bad light and ruin their tourist industry.
"It's like children's theatre for 40-year old gay people!" - XANADU THE MUSICAL