I'd suggest maybe Groundhog Day, Sweeney Todd, or even Sleep No More (more so an immersive experience but I've heard amazing things from everyone who's gone to see it).
Hey all! I know this is a long shot as it is still a few months away, but if I'm going to rush this show mid-November (most likely the weekend before Black Friday). What time would I want to arrive at the theatre to ensure rush tickets?