I agree with you about the characters not all "wearing black hats or white hats." The villains have good in them, and the good people have some bad moments as well.
It makes them more realistic, and it also keeps us guessing as to how things are going to play out.
In addition to O'Brien being such a "baddy" and your mentioning her genuine remorse for the soap incident, she is also very protective of the shellshocked servant. His mother was a lady's maid, and she noticed how good he was with a needle and thread. To see how little she cares for just about all of humanity and then have her not only treat this man with respect but also look out for him is surprising and refreshing. Gives her many more layers as a "person."
Other characters have been the same. Even Lord Grantham, who is largely a "good guy" has had his mean streaks and lapses of judgment. Again, good for Julian Fellows and the scripts for making them all so interesting.
EDIT: And I'll add in Mrs. Crawley, who I think is a fine person and has a terrific work ethic, loves her son, etc. She turned into a genuine pain in the butt and became over-the-top power-hungry when the house turned into a convalescent home. I don't blame Lady Grantham for losing her patience with her and gladly letting her leave when she threatened to. They are both "good guys," but to see them lock horns and challenge each other was unexpected and fascinating.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 1/25/12 at 09:23 PM