Elton John American Idol... (new less confusing thread)- Page 2

[Princess MimiChica]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 11:23am

"American Idol is in trouble this season. And yes; I know the ratings are through the roof. But they are all horrible this year. At this point last season they even had 2 cd's out. It is not happening this year. And Jennifer Hudson was great last night.. but honestly.....taking into account her previous performances.. would you buy her record??? And that Fantasia girl is starting to wear thin. The men should all be eliminated. They are all terrible. "


um, what show are you watching hun? there are about SEVEN amazing singers left, and the Soun cd is coming out next Tuesday. Jennifer has never given a weak performance, and i'd buy her cd tomorrow in a heartbeat. Fantasia has a classic Diva star attitude, I love it!! shes really got It and i'll ne buying her cd too. And, don't get rid of ALL the guys, because George is still great!! (but i still say he;s stright! =P

Once John Stevens is gone, the competition can get serious.

[ckeaton]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 12:03pm

I feel bad for John, because he's too young right now, and I know he feels bad. Did you see the A.I. whatever vignette with George in the big fro... and the kids playing basketball... JS looked so damn uncomfortable...

He's a star now... for one or another reason. But we shouldn't be jumping any redeyes... he doesn't deserve to be kidnapped. America is voting... God knows why, but they are.

[tpdc]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 1:43pm

Princess, go to a gay bar, talk to some of the boys and then comeback and tell us you still think Clay and George are straight. Or maybe you'll come back and tell us you're sure it must have been "straight night" at the bar you went to.

[shermanslave]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 6:07pm

Princess, there is not one gay guy in America who thinks that George is straight. Don't worry, you will realize that later once you have fallen in love with a couple of guys who end up being gay. Happens all the time.

And I think Clay is gay too.

[MyNameInLights]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 7:27pm

Is it bad that I despise JPL more than anything in the universe?

[Zola Q. LaPlaya]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 8:14pm

MyNameInLights:

Don't worry about hating JPL. Just remember:

Everyone's a little bit hateful.

-or-

Loathing. Adulterated loathing.
For his face, his voice, his clothing.

[robyn525600]

Posted: 4/8/04 at 10:07pm

This is my top 3:

1. LaToya
2. George
3. Fantasia

I like Jennifer Hudsons voice but shes not consistent and I think she has a rotten "I'm better than everyone" attitude. Diana is good too but again, not consistent. I think its because she's young - give her 2-4 more years to work on her craft and she will be a powerhouse. The rest of them I couldn't care less about.

[Karma76]

Posted: 4/9/04 at 9:14am

"Is it bad that I despise JPL more than anything in the universe? "



NOOOOOO I agree with you 1000000000000%

I think he is such a talentless garbage pail kid it is not even funny. I have NO idea who is voting for him. Mimichica you said once john stevens leaves it can get serious??? he is way better then JPL who is by far the worse top 12 contestent on american idol I have ever seen and yet keeps hanging on.

[J LA]

Posted: 4/9/04 at 5:14pm

George is Gay???? I don't have "gaydar" apparently. I can't believe John and Jon are not in the bottom three---ever....
Who is voting for them? Fantasia is getting on my nerves, but she will be around for awhile.
Camille deserved to go this week. She was painful to see and hear!
I sure appreciate Elton John a whole lot more:)