Here's what Savage said:
"While the gay episodes demonstrate to MTV's impressionable viewers that young gay people are every bit as shallow, vapid, and crude as their straight counterparts, not one of the gay episodes really worked. Instead of anxiously waiting to see which of the five will be chosen, viewers of the gay installments anxiously wait for the five boys on the bus to strip down and get it on. The gay boys on the Next bus aren't rivals, MTV, they're all potential matches, which makes the one guy who isn't on the bus nearly irrelevant. In all three of the gay episodes I saw, the boys on the bus were more into each other than they were into the boy for whose affections they were supposedly competing; in gay Next the boy who "won" a second date with the boy-who-wasn't-on-the-bus declined, preferring to run off with one of the other guys on the bus. Re-creating the "five bitchy rivals" dynamic that makes the hetero episodes of Next so entertaining wouldn't be that hard. Here's all you need to do: Put five hairy bears on the bus who are only attracted to pretty twinks and let them compete for the, er, hand of one pretty twink. Or five white guys only into Asian guys competing for an Asian guy. Or five tops and one bottom. Or five Log Cabin Republicans and one CPA. Take a little more care with the casting and pre-interviews, and you'll be able to solve Next's gay problem."
The Village Voice
"How do you like THAT 'misanthropic panache,' Mr. Goldstone?" - PalJoey