I'd taught CATCHER IN THE RYE almost every year of my teaching career. When I was a young teacher (38 years ago) the kids loved the novel. They identified with Holden and often devoured the entire book in one night. Parents used to call the school and complain that I'd "over-motivated" their children.
Then, roughly ten years before I retired, the tides changed. Students HATED the novel. To the kids I was teaching at the latter part of my career, the novel was "corny" (TRANSLATION: boring) and Holden was "whack". All those kids wanted to read was PUSH or a prison journal called MONSTER.
I think it's a sad commentary upon society when students want to learn only what they already know.
Still, I pray that J.D. Salinger rests in peace.
"Long live God!" (GODSPELL)