It's not THAT disappointing...the songs from DREAMGIRLS weren't mind blowingly good.
I don't think it's the cast of splitting votes. I think it's a case of people looking at a ballot, seeing a name they know, and checking her name.
For the record, I asked 3 separate friends who they would vote for. I played all 5 songs for them. I was curious as to what they would vote for. They love music, but don't particularly care for musicals.
All 3 chose Melissa Etheridge.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy."
-Charlie Manson