#1
Posted: 3/15/07 at 1:59pm
I posted this link in the Garrison Keillor thread earlier, but this column really ticks me off. It's not even so much the offensiveness of it compared with the fact that this guy really thinks he's brilliant for writing it.
It's bad enough that we have Ann Coulter thinking she's Lenny-freaking-Bruce for an insult to John Edwards that's below the intelligence level of the average "That's So Raven" viewer. Now we have these people who think they're Jonathan Swift just because they dare write some offensive thing about murdering gays or whatever. Kinda like the people who thought what Tim Hardaway said took "courage."
First of all, most attempts I've seen to recreate "A Modest Proposal" have been about as successful as my effort to do so in my high school English class. In this case, the analogy -- hating gays likened to some obscure professor at Kent State -- doesn't even makes sense.
But what's even worse is that even if he meant it as such, it certainly doesn't feel like satire in a world of Eric Rudolphs, in a world of Roanoke bar shootings, in a world where 72-year-old men are beaten to death with pipes after being called a faggot and in a world where men are beaten up for wearing pink pants on the PATH train. Just look at the comments below the column to see how many people think it would be just peachy keen or at least a point of apathy if someone started blowing up gay bars.
So from now on, unless someone is a damn good writer (and this guy, um, ain't), spare me the "it's satire" defense. Somehow, I don't think "A Modest Proposal" would have had the same effect if even a subset of the culture was already munching on baby kidneys in a placenta reduction.
Oh, yeah. The link.
It's bad enough that we have Ann Coulter thinking she's Lenny-freaking-Bruce for an insult to John Edwards that's below the intelligence level of the average "That's So Raven" viewer. Now we have these people who think they're Jonathan Swift just because they dare write some offensive thing about murdering gays or whatever. Kinda like the people who thought what Tim Hardaway said took "courage."
First of all, most attempts I've seen to recreate "A Modest Proposal" have been about as successful as my effort to do so in my high school English class. In this case, the analogy -- hating gays likened to some obscure professor at Kent State -- doesn't even makes sense.
But what's even worse is that even if he meant it as such, it certainly doesn't feel like satire in a world of Eric Rudolphs, in a world of Roanoke bar shootings, in a world where 72-year-old men are beaten to death with pipes after being called a faggot and in a world where men are beaten up for wearing pink pants on the PATH train. Just look at the comments below the column to see how many people think it would be just peachy keen or at least a point of apathy if someone started blowing up gay bars.
So from now on, unless someone is a damn good writer (and this guy, um, ain't), spare me the "it's satire" defense. Somehow, I don't think "A Modest Proposal" would have had the same effect if even a subset of the culture was already munching on baby kidneys in a placenta reduction.
Oh, yeah. The link.