Van has my favorite line in any musical ever in "Brigadoon." When they're sitting in the overly-crowded bar in New York. And it's not even so much the shticky "one-liner" itself as the way Van delivers it with his beaten-down sarcasm. Looking around the bar, he says:
"It's not the heat, it's the humanity."
Love it. Love that kind of humor. Love the simple truth in it.
And JB2, Brigadoon is one of the film musicals that I think is sorely needing a remake. I agree they missed the mark.
That said ... it's a credit to the high quality of the musical source material that many things still shine through. Van's performance as Jeff Douglas is at the top of that list.
And if you think my memory is "hazy" on this movie, I'm watching the Cinemascope version of it right now on my big, fat TV, and it's STILL a good movie. Could have been a great movie, but it's still very good.
Of course, it TANKED in its day. MGM spent a fortune on those Highland sets, even though both Kelly and Minnelli wanted to go on location in Scotland. The sets are still incredible (looking at them now on a 58" Plasma). You can see exactly where the money went, but it was spent in vain. They still look like "really good sets." Gene never should have turned it into a dance movie ... especially at the expense of the vocals. The singing is secondary in this film, and that's it's biggest fault.
But other things to admire:
Truly brilliant cinematography. The opening sequence when the town "wakes up" is shot in such a lovely way. Almost like Jack Cardiff would have done (and that's saying a LOT).
The opening sequence in the square is great! The dancing and staging are first-rate.
The songs. Yes, they lowered them and simplified them. But the melodies and lyrics are still there and they are solid as a rock. Best score that Lerner and Lowe ever wrote, IMO.
Bonnie Jean---the mixing of the Highland dancing with the "hoofing" of Gene Kelly and Van Johnson is wonderful. A culture clash that works on film.
The virtual "unknown" who plays Charlie Dalrymple. His name is Jimmy Thompson. He's gorgeous to look at and does his own singing. Gene Kelly also used him to sing the "Beautiful Girls" number in Singin' in the Rain. I don't know why he had such a limited career at MGM, but he is wonderful in the movie.
Anyway, watch it for Van. It's a great role for him, and he nails every line and moment in it.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 12/12/08 at 08:19 PM