What about The 39 Steps?
It depends what you enjoy most about musicals.
YF has spectacular sets, a great cast (currently at least), excellent choreography and a very funny script.
AQ has a simple set, a small cast (some of whom are excellent and some of whom are ok) and a very witty script.
I saw both of them in May and absolutely loved YF. I also enjoyed AQ but YF is the one I would see again if I could. I paid $120 for YF and got center seats 4 rows from the stage.
My AQ ticket was $70 for center 7 rows back. This was too far back I felt for this show.
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/12/05
Avenue Q
Stand-by Joined: 6/1/06
I agree with the Passing Strange recommendation, but of the shows you have listed, I'd go with Avenue Q.
Young Frankenstein! hands down.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/5/08
Tale of Two Cities...if you like epics, romance, and great theater in general...the sets, lighting, costumes and actors will not disappoint you :)...and the music is amazing, too!
You probably can get cheap tickets, since it will still be in preview, then.
Chorus Member Joined: 10/30/07
I agree ...Tale of Two Cities is the show to see...I saw it in Florida expected to hate it and I Loved IT!!!!!! I would put this one at the top of you list! This show moved me , its the best show I have seen in a long time.
If you're in town in August why don't you be daring and go off-off-broadway. From August 8th - 24th, 2008 the NYC International Fringe Festival will be running. There are performances of many various shows during the day (each venue can do 4 or 5 performances in one day) and there are many , many venues, so it doesn't have to use up your "On Broadway" time.
The full schedule and performance times have not been announced yet - but their site is http://www.fringenyc.org/
August: Osage County --- You won't regret it.
Videos