Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#1

A Catered Affair last night

I'm really easy to impress when it comes to brodaway-I admit that willingly, I'm like a little child in a candy store the minute I enter a theater... but I was really not wowed by this performance, I mean good cast, a few good songs but I didn't find anything truly spectacular about it.. I almost feel bad saying it because I was so looking forward to it- but really, I feel like it's underdeveloped a little maybe. I'd still recommend people to see it - just if you have other shows you want to see, see them first. unless they're glory days or cry baby..


Last note, I wish Matt C. had had a bigger part because I thought the little part he did have was really good.
#2

re: A Catered Affair last night

shh282, I felt the same way, and I also tend to like a lot of what I see. I didn't think it was horrible, but I can't remember many songs from the show. I thought the "Vision" number was beautiful, but other than that, eh.
The people sitting around me had no idea it was going to be kind of a downer. That advertising is a tad deceptive.
The Overture is part of the show, people. Please shut your pie hole.
#3

re: A Catered Affair last night

I saw yesterday's matinee and, overall, found the whole thing to be dreary, with what I felt was a non-existent score -- it was like background music, at most.

Having said that (I didn't care for the show, if anyone hasn't guessed), one performance was a knockout -- and I'm not talking Faith Prince or Harvey Fierstein. Tom Wopat was absolutely terrific -- singing and acting were topnotch and he almost made you care about this rather humdrum person. I've seen him before but he never had this impact on me. Now, if he could just find a better show to showcase his talents . . . .

BroadwayEd

Updated On: 5/4/08 at 12:48 PM

#4

re: A Catered Affair last night

It was an odd experience for me. There was so much obvious love and talent poured into the show... yet, it still left me flat.

The authors never entirely convinced me that these are singing characters. So when they started to sing, it cut into the less-is-more demands of the is very simple story.

I think I will end up loving the cast recording separately from the show as a whole.





What great ones do the less will prattle of

Updated On: 5/4/08 at 01:04 PM

#5

re: A Catered Affair last night

"it was like background music, at most. "

Well, Bucchino intended for much of the music to work as scoring like on a film. I'm sorry you didn't enjoy the score--I think it's beautiful.

"The authors never entirely convinced me that these are singing characters."

Oh, I was convinced. I think to say that there are characters who are not "singing characters" implies that you believe that there can be characters/people in this world with absolutely no emotions.

I think quite the opposite is true of these characters.

johnraymondbarker.com
#6

re: A Catered Affair last night

Oh.. I hope I didn't imply THAT!

I loved the characters in Catered Affair. I just felt that songs ... or a least the songs in this score.. said more than needed to be said.

I sensed what was going on emotionally from the actors, dialogue and situations. What was not being directly stated was very powerful...sometimes the songs, to me, put just too fine a point on things.

I even wondered a couple times if music, however lovely, was even necessary to telling this story.





What great ones do the less will prattle of

Updated On: 5/4/08 at 10:18 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $95
Hot Show
Tickets From $71