As to why one "shouldn't" sleep with him...
Evidently, he's quite the lothario. Great interview with him in the NYTimes when Piazza was in Seattle, where they also interviewed his mother, who said he had the proclivities of a satyr, or - get this - "of his grandfather." Rodgers was a notorious womanizer.
In fact, I've read somewhere that "Come to Jesus" is in many ways autobiographical. I don't know how! But it's interesting... And also, in the same interview his mother said that there was some musical this woman he had dumped had written, very Company-like in that it was this one really talented, handsome, charming guy, leaving women all over New York.
And also he has dealt with a lot of personal demons for years including drug addiction.
All of that should perhaps keep you away from him? (Not that it would me) I'd say go for it, just know what you're getting into to.
And I reiterate along w/ everyone else: He is hot. I've fallen for him completely. (which is too bad really)
Also: did it seem to any of you that he was WASTED on the Tony Awards? It was almost embarassing. But then a lot of people this year seemed to have been hitting the bottle even before they got there.
Renegade Shakespeare Company