This was just painful to sit through. It was vocally all over the place, with melodies going completely wayward and harmonies being muddled. I'm "The Story Goes On," one of the more popular songs from the show, being belted out powerfully and hitting you with a wall of sound. Here, it was sung purely in a shrill head voice by Liz Flemming with the high notes being completely missed. She is the Artistic Director of the company, which makes me wonder if an audition process was even held for the role. Definitely the weakest link in the cast.
The direction had no clear point of view. The decision to update it to 2019 (Pam and Nick as a lesbian couple, switching genders for the smaller roles, changing parts of the book/lyrics) seemed admirable, but not enough work was done for it to make sense during several parts of the show. I kept trying to justify certain changes, but it was clear that they weren't fleshed out thoroughly.
There were some positive aspects. Evan Ruggiero was incredibly charming and the highlight of the show. Alice Ripley, though her "Patterns" was rough, had lovely stage presence and was emotionally grounded. Christina Sajous and Gabrielle McClinton had great chemistry. Overall a lackluster performance. Pretty upset as I've loved the score for years.