I saw the 4/26 evening perf. There was tremendous murmuring going on as Boris Kodjoe is seen at the start of the play; I mean, the man is a total stud. That said, I think both physically and as an actor, I'm sure Terrance Howard was much better as Brick. I think he could better do that whiny, self-pitying attitude that Brick has. Enough with the disgust already, Brick! Be a man! Kodjoe was a bit of a shell, too quiet, too removed.
I thought that the African-American cast, and the "Tyler Perry" audience (if you want to call it that), actually injected the play with some contemporary relevance. Star Jones, Terry McMillan, everybody knows the story of a black woman married to a man on the down low.
The relevation for me was Phylicia Rashad. I thought she was great as Big Mama, bringing a wonderful pathos to the long faithful wife and mother, but also an underlying strength that I think the audience (largely black) could relate to. (Interestingly, I was in a way reminded of Edith Bunker.) At the end of the play (spoiler) when Big Daddy says he's going up to the roof to survey his domain and Big Mama pleads, 'Sweatheart, can I come with you?' well, I wasn't the only one with tears in my eyes.
I would agree that the direction was a bit uneven, and failed to highlight some of the big lines or scenes. When Brick says 'Big Daddy, I'm shocked!' it just didn't have any impact (I'm not sure if that was Kodjoe's fault or the direction). A little cutting wouldn't have hurt either, IMO, as the show was a bit long (2 intermissions). While not a great production, I give it props for bringing contemporary resonance, and showing how Tennessee Williams was ahead of his time in terms of gay issues (gay athletes; husbands on the DL; gay couple--the plantation's original owners). Were the 1950's audiences shocked by such things? Even in 2008 some of the lines in the play brought gasps.
Coach Bob knew it all along: you've got to get obsessed and stay obsessed. You have to keep passing the open windows. (John Irving, The Hotel New Hampshire)