withoutatrace: I believe that what you are saying is offensive to all gay actors. As Olivieri once said when asked if he could play a straight part 'that's why they call it acting'. Besides the song is about love and everyone, gay, straight...whatever...can relate to love and loss.
Sondheim wrote a beautiful song and Lane sang it onstage with just the right amount of pathos. He is not Pavarotti, but you don't have to be to sing this song.
For those of you who did not get the chance to see the show, I know there were detractors on the boards (as there always are) but it was a quirky musical with lots of thoughtful content that we needed at that point in our country -- and still do.
Hope it is revived at some point. In the meantime, the OCR is great. Gotta love bart and lane together.
"Life is a lesson in humility"