Hehe. I was a baritone once. I'll try to stay with uptempos, but some of these ballads I can't help but suggest...
"Do I Love You Because You're Beautiful" from Cinderella - It's amazing how little people use this song. It's in great baritone range and is just long enough for audition length. Very simple, very nice.
"Fireworks" from Do Re Mi - It's a definite "boom-chuck" song, but it's very classic Broadway style. It's sung by a straight guy, but sometimes I think it should be sung by Carmen Ghia, because it kind of makes me feel like that when I sing it. Haha.
"A Foggy Day" by Gershwins - Not sure what show it's from, but it's a nice midtempo that no one sings and has a nice "money note" moment on an F.
"Loving You" from Passion - Yes, it IS Sondheim, but it's surprisingly easy. Also, it's originally sung by a woman, and I don't know many guys that will venture into that territory. It's for a soprano woman, so it fits nicely into a baritone range. The non-solo version is nice and short, but it still needs a few measures cut.
"No Other Love" by R&H - Don't know what show, but again lands on a nice fat F at the end of the song. It's in a slow "tango" tempo.
"Tonight At Eight" from She Loves Me - It's definitely an acting song, and doesn't necesarilly show off the voice that much. It's also a patter song, and doesn't go very high.
"On The Other Side Of The Tracks" from Little Me - Also a girl song, but it's got a great driving tempo and is quite the showstopper. You can get it at www.sunhawk.com and change the key to whatever you want. Definitely a jazz/Broadway belt song.
"Anytime (I Am There)" from Elegies - It's a William Finn song, but it's a very easy William Finn song. The money note is an F#, which is kind of getting out of a baritone's range. It's a midtempo and is a great acting piece. The guys key says "Norm" on the title page, I believe, because it's the version he sings in the Infinite Joy concert. It's also not legit, but it's a great song.
Break a leg with your audition! I hope I was some help. Are you going for any other schools? Boco? CCM? UMich? NWestern? Carnegie-Mellon?
Eeeeeeyyyyyyyyaaaaaaaannnnnddddd aaaaaaaiiiiiiiiyyyyyyaaaaaammmmmmmm teeeeeeeelllllliiiiiinnngg yyyyooooooouuuuuuuwwwaaaahh...