I've been listening to the album for about a year now, and I finally got to see the show yesterday. Even though I already knew all of the jokes (in the songs, at least) there was so much happening visually, and in the touring cast's interpretations of the material that I still found myself laughing just as much as the people around me who clearly had no idea what they were in for (Atlanta, GA, what do you expect?). After the show, and after listening to the album one more time, I feel that the original cast is the best cast to have on the recording, but I'm really glad that I saw the cast I did! I hope this show sticks around for at least a few more years!
-- SDG