BEST THEATER EXPERIENCE EVER TONIGHT!

I'm sure that was pretty awesome to see, but I think they need to let the show stand on its own. If I want to see Green Day in concert I'll pay for to see one of their concerts.

I know that sounds cynical, in a way, but I like to see the show itself and not so much the creators, unless it's opening or closing night.

I felt the same way with the promotion of '21 Guns'. The female leads get their moment to shine in a public performance, but the male leads don't because Billie Joe Armstrong assumes the male vocals. I know it's his song, but within the context of the Broadway Show it's not.

Keven520, I can see where your coming from but I disagree. I think that with the popularity of the American Idiot cast album both with theatre fans and non theatre fans alike, the full cast version of 21 Guns sans Billy Joe on vocals is getting its chance to be heard.

Also, wasn't there a version of the song recorded without Billy Joe on vocals? I don't mean the one that is on the cast recording. I thought that there was a version of the song recorded with Matt Caplan prior to his being replaced. However, I could be wrong.

Regardless, I always viewed the 21 Guns single as more of a promo for the show and a way to showcase the new orchestrations etc.

There had been times during the course of Movin' Out for example, where Billy Joel would visit the show and get onstage and do New York State Of Mind. Now, by having Billy get on the stage of the Richard Rodgers and sing a song (granted, one that wasn't in the show) have the effect of him not letting it go and stepping back? No, it is viewed by most as a fun encore and something that the original artist did for fun.

---

^ that makes sense. However, I agree that they should let the show stand on its own. I get that the band probably feels very tied to and protective of the material, and they're probably just excited to continue to be a part of the show, but I think a little distance between the two might be good. I also agree that recording "21 Guns" was...weird. It's not even from AMERICAN IDIOT (the album), right? I don't know too much about Green Day. And it also seems strange to me to feature the female leads in a promotional way as a draw to the show when it seems like, in the actual show, they don't get much time in the spotlight.

---

I'm sure that was pretty awesome to see, but I think they need to let the show stand on its own. If I want to see Green Day in concert I'll pay for to see one of their concerts.

Absolutely! When I see A Little Night Music, I hope to GOD Sondheim doesn't come out afterward and give an impromptu performance of numbers from Company or Sweeney. Just LET IT GO, Steve!

---

"I'm sure that was pretty awesome to see, but I think they need to let the show stand on its own. If I want to see Green Day in concert I'll pay for to see one of their concerts. "


What a bunch of bla ..bla... bla....

Jeff it sounds like you had a awesome experience. That is wonderful. And you will never forget it.

---

--Kevn520

The promotion of "21 Guns" was something that they decided to do more for the cast than themselves. If you watched the MTV special about American Idiot being put on Broadway, Billie Joe said something to the extent of, "while we were performing '21 Guns' every night on tour, these kids were performing it every night in Berkeley." So he decided it would be cool to get together and do a recording together.

Also, there was indeed a version recorded with Matt Caplan doing the male vocals instead of Bille Joe.

As far as your comment goes about Green Day only showcasing the females at the Grammy's...you are forgetting that it was the Grammy's. Green Day could have easily decided to do the song themselves and not include the cast at all. If it were the Tony's, I would have an issue with it. I will go on record predicting that Green Day will be involved at the Tony's somehow...my guess would be playing the instruments while the cast performs the song(s).

As a Green Day fan since 1995, and a theatre fan for about the same amount of time, I can say that I'm thrilled to see this finally happen. My two passions in life have merged and it looks absolutely amazing.

Updated On: 4/23/10 at 06:54 PM

Kevin420 know ur facts before you chime in your neg comments . This show is standing tall on it's own . I was there last nite and it was one of the best times I've ever had as well . Why do you all love to ruin a good thread . Post under reviews will ya !!! "Do you know the enemy ? We won a contest! They were there as a thanks to fans from MTV.

First off, it's Kevn520 if you want to lecture me about getting facts straight. I changed my opinion in a subsequent reply, saying that it was understandable that they were there because of the MTV contest.

Also, I didn't say that the show was not standing on its own. I'm actually looking forward to seeing this on Saturday. And seriously, if my comments "ruined" this thread, maybe BWW isn't the best place for you.