I just think that even with good reviews, in this day, it's a tough sell. The key will be a youthful, talented cast attempting to make it fresh, but you've still got a major hurdle with the subject matter.
I just can't see people lining up to pay $200 to go to Sunday school.
Originally, Godspell was a fresh idea (or fresh enough). It was part of a growing movement that explored "the old" through "new" eyes. A youthful vision and vibe. It also was an Off-Broadway show with an experimental "fringe festival" feel. But really the "vibe" was greater than both the material and the production.
Now that "vibe" is a period piece itself, so you're left with judging the material, the subject, and the production values (including the cast) on their own merits. And uptown, on the Great White Way. They're more exposed, this time.
In the '60s and early '70s, religion was still a big/hot topic, but it wasn't anywhere near as polarizing as it is today. All you have to do is mention Jesus and God today and quote scripture, and people's heads explode. "Godspell" is nothing but Holy scripture set to music.
If I were them, I would be doing everything possible to recapture that "vibe," from the moment an audience walks in the theatre. And that's something you can't get from watching a rehearsal video (something they probably shouldn't have released). If they can get audiences in the right mood and frame of mind BEFORE the show starts, it might work. If not, they'll just be seeing this material for what it is.
Bible School: The Musical
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22