This isn't a Broadway story, but years ago in Dallas (I was either an eighth grader or a freshmen in high school 1988 or 1989) - friends of the family were over at my house talking about how much they enjoyed seeing a performance of the national tour of The King and I starring Stacey Keach the night before. They left about 1:40 PM.
My mom said to me - "Would you like to go?" I said "Yes!". She drove me downtown to the Music Hall at Fair Park for a performance at 2:00 PM (the last show in Dallas). I don't know how we made it that fast, but we made it there in 10 minutes (usually 30 in good traffic). She dropped me off - she was simply driving me!
As I was walking up to the entrance, this man approached me and asked me if I needed a ticket. I said yes, but was weary. He said he had a good seat for $45.00. I told him, I only had $25.00. It was 2:00 PM. He sold me the ticket for $25.00!
I was nervous when I walked up to the entrance, but they took my ticket! Yeah, I was in!
When I got to my seat in the orchestra (Row H, left center), there were people sitting in my seat. I asked them if they had the right seat and they showed me their tickets. They said it must have been a mistake. Because I was nervous about the ticket, I didn't go get an usher. I just sat in the seat I was assigned to in the row behind them. During intermission, these old ladies behind me asked if I was in the right seat. I explained that I should be in the row in front of me, but the people in front of me said that they must have made a mistake in ticketing. They were supposed to me in my row! Because the theater was practically empty, it didn't matter where people were sitting. In fact, there were more people sitting in front of me at the beginning of ACT II. I finally figured out that the people in my seat were actually from the balcony!
Oh, yeah - Stacey Keach wasn't that bad. I remember that it was a good looking production (this before the revival, of course which I saw on tour with Haeley Mills (my eyes rolling)).
When I sold Ticketmast tickets in high school and college, people would come up and buy like rows of open seats (that would open up an hour before the show) at the last minute for sold out rock shows - then they would go to the show and sell them. So, there can be legit scalpers.
But I think I would be scared to buy now - unless it was dirt cheap and under profit like the ones that I bought and it looked like a real ticket.
myspace.com/robinsparkles