Saw it this weekend and was very impressed. I'm so glad to see Reagle getting out of its comfort zone and doing SO WELL with INTO THE WOODS. I love the show, one of my faves, and Reagle did a great job with it on the whole. The voices were stellar! Not a weak link. And the orchestra was quite lush. Loved it.
The acting was superbly layered in some cases (Rachel York as the Witch - just devastatingly powerful and poignant, McCaela Donovan as Cinderella - simply glorious, Greg Stone as Jack - very touching with a great arc, and the two Princes, Ayal Miodovnik and Brennan Roach - Agony was a hoot). Some of the acting disappointed (the Baker's Wife in particular, she wasn't warm at all), and some of the characters didn't get all of the humor or subtext. But I blame the director for that. The talent was clearly there. The staging was also kind of clunky when the entire ensemble was on board, and choreography was non-existent! Many lost opportunities for visual humor, especially with Red and the Wolf, the Princes, and the Step Sisters. The narrator was also hampered by reading from an actual book he carried through the entire show. It really tied his hands and kept him from engaging well. Totally unnecessary and wrong headed.
The combo of set and lighting was very effective moodwise and really visually appealing. Loved the idea of the pages as backdrops and cut-out trees. But the massive unit block of steps center stage really hampered movement and caused some late entrances/cues. The idea was probably great on paper, but it didn't work in practice to keep the intertwined story elements moving as fluidly as necessary. It hurt the pace and energy a tad. Staging was most effective in the more intimate numbers. The levels and lighting made for some very nice tableaus.
The music direction and execution were without a doubt the strongest elements in the show. GREAT voices and song interpretations. No One Is Alone, Stay With Me, Witch's Lament, Last Midnight, Children Will Listen, all incredibly moving. There were tears in my eyes a number of times. And I must repeat: Rachel York and McCaela Donovan were stunning.
Well worth the trip to the 'burbs, definitely.
Boston Globe Review