I saw this last night. I think this show could be much improved without an act break and some trimming in act 1. I found act 1 very frustrating and ambling along with a paper thin plot and many scenes that convey the same point as the scene before them. There was also very funny mishap involving a doll and a leg that fell off!!!
I don't love the score as much as others here. I loved skating and many songs in act 2 (Kenita Miller's Granny song is AMAZING) but lots in act 1 I felt like I was always reaching for more of a melody.
Act 2 is mostly great, and I thought Nikki really shined. She is the reason to see this and thought she showed off her comedic skills here even more than Book of Mormon.
I as considering leaving after Act 1, but have to say it was very much glad I stayed for Act 2. It's definitely worth seeing and I feel especially for the set they built it should have run through the weekend. I hope Nikki M James has many more leading parts in her future.