I tried to rush for the Tuesday matinee. Like you, I had rushed a few years ago and it was super easy to just walk up and get a ticket. I thought since it was an unusual performance time due to the holiday, it would be a breeze so I got there a little after 9am, The line was probably at least 50 people. When I eventually got to the window (the line moved quick), I was told they weren't doing rush during the holidays and would resume on 1/3. She did offer me some tickets at a discount. I looked after I got back to my room and the prices were the same as if I had used a discount code from Theater Mania.