Time Out New York takes a second look at Doubt in the current issue. They don't have reviews on their website, but here are some highlights from critic Adam Feldman's review:
"These days, it is rare for a Broadway play to make you think even once; to make you think twice is an accomplishment of substance. Many plays burn brightly onstage and extinguish themselves in the process, but the shadow of Doubt follows you home from the theatre."
...
"After my first encounter with Doubt, I came to a firm conclusion about Father Flynn’s guilt; at the Walter Kerr, my opinion was almost reversed. Yet this apparently central question is of secondary importance. Shanley is less concerned with factual certainty than with moral certitude; his eloquent writing weaves the play’s complex considerations - faith and modernity, truth and consequences - into a terribly fine and human brocade. If you haven’t seen Doubt yet, see it. And if you have, see it again."
"Gif me the cobra jool!"