I've been getting Facebook ads for Beetlejuice showing 4 tickets for $250 (though of course now that I'm looking for that ad it's not showing up, so I'm not sure the details like seat location, code to use, etc)
I’ve heard from several sources that winning the Tootsie lottery is almost a give-in. So i’d probably just try that. Worst case scenario you don’t win, and then can just scoop up a ticket from the TKTS booth.