Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Yesterday I took my daughter to the opening night performance of Disney's High School Musical at the BayWay Arts Center on Long Island. The rest of the run is already sold out, so I'm not going to give you a review or driving directions or anything like that. Just some feedback as a parent.

Something's different about this show. It's a generational thing. HSM seems to be a runaway hit with girls born between Rent and Mamma Mia, who are too old for puppet shows but too young for Avenue Q. And it might just be the Grease or Bye Bye Birdie of their generation. It may not be Tony material, but it is a tween phenomenon that deserves some respect and attention.

Btw, this is not the concert tour, which comes to Long Island at the end of December. But I think it could be the first New York City metro area production of HSM, which debuted as a TV movie in January on the Disney Channel and as a staged musical in August at Stagedoor Manor. Next year a hundred high schools will probably do it. This was put on by the Broadhollow Theatre Company, a non-profit that does 18 shows a year at three Nassau and Suffolk locations.

We have seen several other Broadhollow productions, including Anything Goes this year and Gypsy last year. HSM was of similar quality and competence. It was, however, the biggest crowd we'd ever seen at one of their shows. And while retirees made up most of the audience during our past visits, even parents were outnumbered at Saturday's 4pm matinee.

It's kids performing for even younger kids, primarily girls aged 5 to 12. Looking at the crowd behind us, there'd be two or three little girls with eyes barely above seatback level, then a parent's head, then a few more girls on booster seats, then a parent, then a little brother in his carseat. A few blue-haired oldsters here and there, but a solid half the house was pre-teen, five foot and under. Very few teens and almost no twenty-somethings!

The girls sat quietly and attentively for the most part, like they were happy to be there, exhibiting none of the bad kid behaviors we've seen on display at past holiday shows, except when they occasionally sang along to their favorite verses. For that minor transgression they can be forgiven, though they should be taught it has no place on Broadway (except perhaps at Wicked). Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Many girls wore their favorite HSM t-shirts, which I'm still not sure if that's a good trend or not. Very few young ticketholders left their seats during the first act for bathroom breaks or chats with mommy, though they were decidedly more fidgety and restless during the second act. It's a long show (2.5 hours), so maybe a longer intermission with mandatory bathroom breaks and no sugar snacks might be what these munchkins need.

There are two casts rotating the leads. We saw Brett Campbell as Troy and Elora Rosch as Gabriella, with Victoria Fairclough and Justin Moniz as Sharpay and Ryan. The ensemble included 25 or 30 high school kids, many veterans of past Broadhollow shows. And just two adults, playing the coach and the drama teacher. Kind of like Spring Awakening without the chairs.

The big difference that we noticed from the TV movie was fewer scenes, less dialogue, and more narration by a DJ-like character named Jack Scott (played by Matt Riordan). All the TV songs are still there, plus two new ones: "Cellular Fusion" comes between the auditions and the cafeteria scenes in Act 1, as the kids scheme to derail Troy and Gabriella's plans to sing. Think of "The Telephone Hour" done with flip phones. In Act 2, "Counting On You" is a big production number -- a "Dance at the Gym" between the brainiacs and the jocks.

Oh, did I mention the dancing? There was a lot of it -- probably more than we've seen in any other Broadhollow show. And "Get'cha Head in the Game" may be the first musical theater use of basketballs as both a dance prop and a percussive instrument. Also, at the very end, during a post-curtain-call "High School Music Megamix," half the cast danced down the aisles, drawing out little girls from their seats. Afterwards, the tiny BayWay lobby was packed with autograph seekers and cast members. It was all very cheesy and tweeny and girlie, but parents beware: it's coming to a theater near you.

MTI's list of future productions of HSM
#2

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Ok, I just have to comment about this, because this definitely surprised me. First of all I want to thank you for coming to the show. I hope you enjoyed it! I work at Bayway, and was actually the assistant choreographer for the production (having been in the teen version of it there as well). This entire cast has worked its butt off to make it an enjoyable experience. We are really proud of the response that the show got during the opening performances, and hope for its continued success within the next month. Let me know any more thoughts if you wish.
"People asking questions, lost in confusion. Well I tell them there's no problems, only solutions." ~The one and only John Lennon
#3

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Ponine, my daughter loved the show and so did all the people seated around us, even the boy strapped into his carseat!

Congrats on the dancing. And on the overall quality of the production. I think it's getting a well-deserved sold out run.

But I don't want to get too deep into show review territory. What amazed me was the demographic shift I saw in the seats.
#4

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

HEY!!

So glad you liked the show! I was the skaterdude and the first soloist in the Megamix.....

Thanks for the feedback and publicity.
How Do You Doent Real Life When Real Life's Getting More Like Fiction Each Day??
#5

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

I'm glad you liked it and respect it unlike others. I am currently playing Troy at the Amesbury Playhouse, we were the first to do it since Stagedoor Manor. It opened Nov 3 and it closes this coming Sunday. I'm going to be very sad that it's over, but we also had to shrink it down because of our theater size. Every show has been sold out and we might be bringing it back in the Spring.
#6

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

I'm glad you enjoyed it also! My name is Dariel and I played Martha Cox. The only thing I wanted to say is that the rest of the run ISNT sold out, so if anyone wants to see it the dates are below. This woman saw the white cast, the RED cast is just as talented. Elora still plays Gabriella, but with Tim Buckland as Troy, Nicole Beinhorn as Sharpay Evans and Ryan Raybuck as Ryan Evans. The best thing to do is to call the theatre (631) 581 2700 about ticket sales.

November 28 at 10 WHITE
December 1 at 8 RED
December 2 at 4 RED
December 3 at 3 RED
December 6 at 10 RED
December 9 at 4 WHITE and 8 RED
December 10 at 3 WHITE
December 11 at 10 WHITE
December 16 at 4 RED and 8 WHITE
December 17 at 3 RED
December 23 at 4 WHITE
December 26 at 2 RED
December 28 at ? WHITE
December 29 at 2 WHITE
December 30 at ? RED
#8

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

broadhollow.org, go to now playing, theres a great description


It's based on a Disney CHannel Movie but as its been pointed out, the stage version is much better!!
How Do You Doent Real Life When Real Life's Getting More Like Fiction Each Day??
#9

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

Oh wow, BayWay's in my town, only about 2 minutes from my house. I didn't realize they were doing HSM this year. Sounds like a great production - I will ask around to see if any of my friends in town happened to pick up an extra ticket to one of the shows. Kudos to everyone at Broadhollow - they always put on great performances!
#10

re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip

While I didn't see the show, I am glad to see that pre-teens are finding a musical they can relate to. It is an awesome way to draw kids to the theatre and present something they enjoy. Plus, it is nice and clean unlike so much of the other pop culture directed toward this age group.
re: Disney's High School Musical premiers in East Islip
So, that was the Drowsy Chaperone. Oh, I love it so much. I know it's not a perfect show...but it does what a musical is supposed to do. It takes you to another world, and it gives you a little tune to carry with you in your head for when you're feeling blue. Ya know?

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $101