VintageSnarker said: ""Hearing that this production it coming to Broadway makes me long for the time that every play and musical was original and exciting."
As Hogan points out, many shows throughout the years, quality aside, have been based on something or other. Sometimes the inspiration is just a spark, sometimes it's a full adaptation. For example... South Pacific, Ragtime, A Little Night Music, The Light in the Piazza, Thoroughly Modern Millie, Fun Home"
I doubt that's the era mc1227 was longing for, but much of Shakespeare and virtually all of the Greeks is "unoriginal." And of course Show Boat wasn't original at all.
What we should be longing for is stuff that brings something original and exciting to the material, without regard to whether the source material is original to the stage or not. I see no reason to expect anything less from Guirgis-he is not in the business of giving us crap.