Stand-by Joined: 6/25/06
Would anybody else love to see this made into a Musical?
Broadway Star Joined: 4/27/05
Absolutely not.
Just no.
But if need be, give it to Yazbek.
No.
Not particularly.
If it absolutely HAD to be, I could see it (heavily adapted) working with Bill Finn, although he'd have too much heart with it. I mean, I love the movie, but it doesn't have an ounce of pity in it.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
If it could be done in repertory with Fargo: The Musical, it would be a big hit in Minnesota, but I don't think it's a great idea and it doesn't sing. Sorry.
I didn't want to see this made into a movie so deff not a show.
Broadway Star Joined: 10/26/05
I would love to see someone take on SMILE with a rewritten book... punch up the "bitchy" factor... keep the score.
Broadway Star Joined: 12/31/69
Didn't Smile have several books? I know New York Times online has a review of a mid 90s revisal that went back to Ashman's original "bitchier" script (which they say was replace don Broadway at the request of the producers though I assume with Ashman's full co-operation since he directed the piece) but also updated some bits (with such 90s phrases as politically correct0 but it didn't seem to work...
E
Regarding Smile and other shows like it, haven't any of you people read Not Since Carrie? It's required reading for theatre people. Get it and read it. It will end a lot of your questions about flops.
I understand that it's being updated or that Ken Mandelbaum's writing a sequel. Good for him! There have been a lot of flops since 1986.
I don't really know about this one. I think it works far too well as a movie.
The movie was on last night. Love the film, but enough with the adaptions...UNLESS you can get Allyson Janey to star in it!
"Don't quit the Peeeeeaaaaaaaaaagant"
Broadway Star Joined: 6/29/03
for gods sakes, the woman clung on to your tap shoes while flying through the air like a goddamn lawndart!
skingdom out.
you guys are quoting the wrong parts...the best:
"Peter's gay dad...GAAAAAAYYYY."
The Samuel French version of Smile is sharper and meaner than the Broadway version. Better in my opinion.
I think it would be a great piece for a community theatre to take on. Plus, it fits for Z-list community theatre actors to play the people in the film.
"Get off my dress, you clumsy retard."
I think this would be fantastic!
Broadway Star Joined: 3/17/05
I love this movie but don't see it as a stage show. The "documentary" aspect would be difficult to do onstage--and that is how the story is told for the most part, there aren't many (any) long scenes. Also, I think that while it's definitely a cult movie I don't think it has wide audience appeal. When I saw the movie in the theatre my partner, our friend and I were laughing but the rest of the audience just stared at the screen with their jaws hanging open.
Videos