Josh, you look too young to miss those old movies ;P Really though, this is a great thread. I'm having a hard time thinking of anything because I'm already listening to music but I'll come back to this tomorrow. Here's some random ones I can think of:
"Beautiful" from Sunday in the Park with George, when George is singing, and the counter melodies play. That just kills me. Really, the whole score is very intricate and so heartbreaking and moving...
All of Light in the Piazza, of course.
All of Floyd Collins. I can't believe this one hasn't been mentioned yet! Particularly "How Glory Goes" of course, a song that could probably make me cry without the vocal line. I love the tension in the song and the slow build of emotion and everything. I'm listening to it now :) I think I've worn this CD to pieces.
MTQ, I put "This Nearly Was Mine" on to listen for that. I've never noticed that, it's so subtle! I nearly died! That's HEARTBREAKING.
There's a lot of texture in Follies that I really get into.
The vocal writing in Nine is amazing, I agree. Have you heard "The Germans at the Spa"?
yr ronin,
joey