I have been thinking about this production this week and I was wondering, if it transferd to broadway instead of going the movie route would it have been a hit? I personally think its better than most disney shows on broadway now.
Thoughts?
It's an extremely well-written musical with an earworm-heavy score. You're not wrong that it's way better than anything Disney has on Broadway right now. I was disappointed when I learned that they were going the licensing/TV route rather than Broadway, just because it's so strong. If it ever made it to Broadway, I strongly doubt it'd be a long-runner like the current Disney properties, but I think it could have a really healthy run.
Updated On: 9/5/18 at 10:59 PM
Based on the Disney TV film of it: i thought it was pretty atrocious.
dramamama611 said: "Based on the Disney TV film of it: i thought it was pretty atrocious."
The Disney Channel movie is a mere shell of the show I know and love. The stage version is superior in every way. I hope you get a chance to see the original two-act stage show at some point, if only to more appreciation for what hard work was put into the full product.
If it had come to NYC I think it would've done fairly well. People love the Lohan movie, and would associate a musical with that. I could've seen it running at least a couple years and then touring.
Broadway Star Joined: 11/15/13
I absolutely LOVED this show when I saw it in La Jolla and I agree it is better than anything Disney has on Broadway at the moment. Far superior to Frozen in every way. With very few changes (if any) I think this would have been a huge hit on Broadway. All I thought they needed was a beefed up ensemble ( just a few more cast member) and a bit of stage magic and this show would be pretty close to perfect!
Leading Actor Joined: 2/26/11
I saw it in La Jolla as well...twice (some friends wanted to see it). I loved Blickenstaff, the rest of the show for me was ok/fun, not OMG I'm gonna see this on Broadway soon level of good. I would have liked to have seen Jason Gotay in the cool boy role, though. I respectfully disagree it would have had much long term success on Broadway (I don't even think it sold out the La Jolla run, which Summer, Margaritaville and Hunchback before it all did)
Videos